Renting a car in Italy can turn your holiday into a true adventure — offering freedom, flexibility, and the chance to explore charming villages, hidden beaches, and stunning landscapes at your own pace. 🚗✨
However, Italy’s car rental process has its own quirks, and if you’re not careful, it can lead to unexpected fees, legal headaches, or even ruined travel plans. From ZTL zones to insurance pitfalls, many travelers make the same costly mistakes again and again.
In this complete guide, we’ll reveal the 10 most common (and expensive!) car rental mistakes in Italy — and how to avoid them so your trip runs as smoothly as a scenic Tuscan road.
1️⃣ Not Booking in Advance 🗓️
In Italy, demand for rental cars often exceeds supply — especially in high season. Waiting until the last minute can mean higher prices, fewer options, or no cars at all.
Why it’s risky:
- Prices can double or triple during holidays and summer.
- Popular cars (automatic, SUV, 7-seater) sell out fast.
Pro Tip: Reserve at least 6–8 weeks before travel — even earlier for peak periods like August or Easter.
| Booking Timeframe | Avg. Price per Day (€) | Vehicle Choice Availability |
|---|---|---|
| 2–3 months in advance | 35–45 | Excellent |
| 1–2 weeks in advance | 50–70 | Limited |
| Last-minute (same week) | 80–120+ | Very low |
2️⃣ Ignoring Insurance Details 🛡️
Many travelers focus only on the base rental rate and overlook insurance coverage. While Italian law requires Collision Damage Waiver (CDW) and Theft Protection (TP), these often come with high excess fees — sometimes over €2,000.
Why it’s risky:
- Even a minor scratch can lead to large charges.
- Without full coverage, you may pay out-of-pocket first and claim later.
Pro Tip: Compare full protection options from the rental company or a trusted third-party provider.
| Insurance Type | Covers What? | Excess (€) | Cost per Day (€) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basic (CDW + TP) | Collision + theft | 1,200–2,500 | Included |
| Full Coverage | Collision, theft, glass, tires, roadside | 0 | 15–25 |
3️⃣ Entering ZTL Zones 🚫🏙️
ZTL (Zona Traffico Limitato) areas restrict car access in many Italian cities to reduce traffic. Driving into one without authorization can result in multiple fines, often sent to you months later.
Why it’s risky:
- Fines range from €80–€120 per entry.
- You can get several fines in a single day.
Pro Tip: Park outside the city center and walk or take public transport. Use GPS apps that warn about ZTL areas.
4️⃣ Choosing the Wrong Car Size 🚗➡️🚙
Italy’s medieval towns and countryside roads can be very narrow. Large SUVs might be comfortable but are harder to park and maneuver.
Pro Tip:
✅ Ready to Drive in Rome?
Unlock the best rental deals at Rome Airport in seconds. Fast, flexible, and trusted by millions. Don’t miss out!
- For cities → Small/compact car
- For countryside with luggage → Mid-size hatchback
- For large groups → Minivan, but expect parking challenges
| Car Type | Seats | Luggage Capacity | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Compact | 4–5 | 2–3 small bags | Cities & short trips |
| Mid-size | 5 | 2 large bags | Countryside & mixed driving |
| Minivan/Van | 7–9 | 4–6 large bags | Families & group travel |
5️⃣ Misunderstanding Fuel Policy ⛽
Most Italian rentals use a Full-to-Full policy: you receive the car full of fuel and must return it full. Failing to refill can mean inflated refueling charges.
Pro Tip: Always refill at a nearby station before drop-off and keep the receipt.
| Policy Type | How It Works | Best Choice |
|---|---|---|
| Full-to-Full | Pick up full, return full | ✅ Yes |
| Full-to-Empty | Pay for fuel upfront, return empty | ❌ No |
| Prepaid Fuel | Pay for a set amount, no refund for unused | ❌ No |
6️⃣ Forgetting About Transmission Type ⚙️
In Italy, most cars are manual. Automatics are in limited supply and more expensive.
Why it’s risky:
- Booking late means you might be stuck with manual only.
- Automatic surcharges can be €10–€20 per day.
Pro Tip: If you need an automatic, book early and be ready for higher rates.
7️⃣ Skipping the Vehicle Inspection 📸
Before you drive away, inspect the car carefully — exterior, interior, and even under the bumpers.
Pro Tip:
- Photograph every scratch and dent.
- Ensure all existing damage is recorded in the rental agreement.
This protects you from being blamed for pre-existing issues.
8️⃣ Forgetting About Toll Roads 🛣️
Italy’s autostrade (highways) charge tolls, which can add up quickly on long trips.
Pro Tip:
- Bring cash or a credit card for toll booths.
- For frequent trips, ask about a Telepass device.
| Route Example | Toll (€) One-Way | Distance (km) |
|---|---|---|
| Rome → Florence | 18–20 | 275 |
| Milan → Venice | 25–28 | 270 |
| Naples → Bari | 15–17 | 260 |
9️⃣ Underestimating One-Way Drop-Off Fees 💶
Returning a rental car to a different city or airport can involve steep fees.
Pro Tip: Compare round-trip vs. one-way rental prices before booking.
| Pick-Up / Drop-Off Location | One-Way Fee (€) |
|---|---|
| Rome → Florence | 70–90 |
| Milan → Naples | 150–200 |
| Venice → Palermo (Ferry) | 250–300 |
🔟 Returning the Car Late ⏰
Even a 1-hour delay can result in being charged for an extra day.
Pro Tip: Return the car 30–60 minutes before the official time and allow extra for traffic or fuel stops.
✅ Extra Tips for a Smooth Rental Experience
- 📅 Book as early as possible in high season.
- 🛡 Consider full coverage to avoid stress.
- 🚫 Avoid ZTL zones at all costs.
- 📸 Take plenty of photos at pickup and drop-off.
- ⛽ Always refill before returning.
